Settlement in a Criminal Case?

Credit goes to google.com for this image.

It is not uncommon to us that most of the criminal cases filed in courts, before they reached a full-blown trial stage, they were settled by the parties. As a consequence, those cases were dismissed.

Is this really the case?  Criminal Cases, can they be settled?

It is not.  They cannot be settled.

A criminal case, when filed in court, it is not the victim who would stand as the complainant against the offender or the accused.  It is the people for that matter, for instance People of the Philippines, that files the case in court.  The victim, on the other hand, would only serve as a complaining witness/es to prove the allegation.

In short, it is the State which files any criminal case. 

Because of this, a criminal case filed in court is deemed not for settlement.  The State cannot just enter into compromise between the accused criminal without jeopardizing the welfare of its citizenry.  

However, the State cannot prohibit any victim to enter into settlement with regards to the CIVIL ASPECT of the case with the accused.  This civil aspect of the case involves the CIVIL LIABILITY of the crime charged.  This civil liability may be in a form of damages or the legal costs and fees the victim suffers in filing the case.

When the victim and the accused entered into settlement, what has been settled is the civil aspect or liability of the case.  It is not the criminal charge that has been settled.

Notwithstanding the settlement of the civil aspect of the case, the State may still proceed in prosecuting the crime. 

However, considering that the victim is the primary witness of the State to prosecute the crime and considering further that the civil aspect was already settled, the victim would have no more interest to continue prosecuting the same.  Thus, due to the lack of interest of the victim to pursue prosecuting the crime, the State losses its vital and primary witness against the accused.  In this case, the criminal charge shall be dismissed.

Hence, the criminal case may be dismissed not because due to the settlement of the civil aspect but due to the lack of interest of the victim to pursue prosecuting the crime against the accused.

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Philippine Laws on Illegal Gambling

Image
Since the announcement of Philippine President Rodrigo Roa Duterte for the Philippine National Police to halt its operation on war against drugs and shift the fight against illegal gambling, hundreds of suspected individuals were apprehended allegedly involved with illegal gambling nationwide. In General Santos City for instance, there are at least 4 suspects are brought before our office for inquest investigation.  There suspects are either violating Presidential Decree (P.D.) No. 1602 or Republic Act No. 9287. It might be noteworthy to consider because the police officers are doing their job as mandated by law, but, most, if not all, of the suspects apprehended belong to the poorest of the poor.  We are still waiting at the time when we would face suspects who are the financier of these illegal gambling games. This image is taken from google. The following are the gambling laws of the Philippines: PRESIDENTIAL DECREE NO. 1602 It amended the criminal provisions of A
Read more

Bonds for Illegal Gambling

This post shall provide the updated recommended bonds for illegal gambling as of this writing. Presidential Decree No. 1602 (Prescribing Stiffer Penalties on Illegal Gambling): Section 1.   Penalties.  The following penalties are hereby imposed: (a) The penalty of prison correccional in its medium period of a fine ranging from one thousand to six thousand pesos, and in case of recidivism, the penalty of prision mayor in its medium period or a fine ranging from five thousand to ten thousand pesos shall be imposed upon:      1. Any person other than those referred to in the succeeding sub-sections who in any manner, shall directly or indirectly take part in any illegal or unauthorized activities or games of cockfighting, jueteng, jai alai or horse racing to include bookie operations and game fixing, numbers, bingo and other forms of lotteries; cara y cruz, pompiang and the like; 7-11 and any game using dice; black jack, lucky nine, poker and its derivatives, monte, baccarat, cuajao, pang
Read more

The Crime of Grave Scandal

Image
Courtesy of Sun.Star Davao When I opened my facebook yesterday, June 2, 2014, a strange news caught my attention.  This news was all about two men caught in the act masturbating.  Thus: DUHA ka lalaki ang gibalhog sa selda sa San Pedro Police Station human nasakpang nag-masturbate sila ala 1:25 sa kaadlawon kagahapon, Dominggo, didto sa Palma Gil Street, siyudad sa Davao. Ang duha gitago sa pangalan nga Marco, 33, ulitawo, laborer, nagpuyo sa San Juan Village, Bangkal, Barangay Talomo Proper, ug Daryl, 23, ulitawo, sales agent ug residente sa S.I.R, New Matina, Barangay 76-A Bucana. Gisaysay sa blotter sa kapulisan nga nadakpan ang duha sa nagpatrolya ang mga sakop sa Philippine Civic Crime Monitoring Group (PCCMG) nga gipangulohan Jerry Balobar Ponayo didto sa dalang Palma Gil. Si Police Officer (PO2) Perfecto Tuloy, duty desk officer, nagsulti nga nakita mismo ni Ponayo ang duha nga nagbinatilay sa ilang kinatawo kilid sa gi-parking nga multicab sa kalsada.
Read more